New Boss? How to Manage Up Without Losing Yourself
When you’re an experienced manager and a new boss arrives, the dynamic can shift overnight.
Suddenly you’re navigating someone else’s expectations, communication style, and decision rhythm - all without shared history.
Your team still looks to you for direction.
Your boss looks to you for delivery.
And you’re stuck in the middle trying to make both sides work.
1. Take Control of the First 1:1s
Don’t wait for your new boss to set the tone - set it yourself.
Book the first few 1:1s early. Come prepared with:
- A short team overview - strengths, current challenges, delivery priorities.
- Your preferred ways of working (updates, Slack vs. email, decisions vs. discussion).
- Questions to understand their world:
- “What’s your vision for this team?”
- “How do you prefer to receive updates?”
- “What does success look like for you in the next 90 days?”
This isn’t about over-managing; it’s about showing initiative and building alignment.
2. Map Their Personality Type - Not Just Their Role
Every boss filters the world differently.
Understanding how they think helps you communicate what matters most.
One client realised their new boss was highly task-driven but low on people focus.
They translated team updates into metrics instead of emotion - friction dropped overnight.
Frameworks like DISC or NLP Meta Programmes can help:
Are they detail-oriented or big-picture? Risk-avoidant or opportunity-seeking? Structured or flexible?
The more you observe, the easier it is to influence without friction.
3. Set the Emotional Tone Early
Your team trusts you already. Your new boss doesn’t - yet.
That makes you both bridge and barometer.
If you’re anxious, they’ll sense it.
If you model curiosity and collaboration, they’ll follow suit.
Try saying:
“I want to make sure the team feels supported during this transition.
What can I do to help you land well - and where should I step back?”
That one question builds psychological safety both ways.
4. Document Agreements, Not Just Conversations
New leaders often adjust priorities as they settle in.
When you agree on direction or KPIs, summarise it in writing:
“Just to confirm today’s chat: I’ll continue owning the delivery roadmap,
and we’ll revisit team structure at the end of Q1. Let me know if I missed anything.”
This reduces confusion, prevents micromanagement, and creates clarity for both sides.
5. Don’t Assume They Know Your Value
If your previous boss trusted you implicitly, you might be used to working quietly.
But a new boss lacks that context. Make your impact visible early.
In leadership syncs, frame updates around outcomes and impact, not just activity:
“Here’s what changed as a result of last sprint’s delivery…”
It’s not self-promotion - it’s strategic communication.
Key Takeaway: You Can Lead Upwards Too
Having a new boss isn’t just a challenge - it’s an opportunity to reset influence and visibility.
Handled well, it can:
- Strengthen trust and credibility.
- Reduce friction across layers.
- Position you as a reliable, proactive leader.
If you’re adjusting to new leadership above you, remember - you can lead from where you are.
Book a free chemistry call
Supporting tech managers to lead better teams.